Monday, April 18, 2011

Mentally-Ill, Sexually-Violent Prisoners, the Constitution, and Health-Care Reform.

Do you object if mentally-ill, sexually-violent federal prisoners are confined beyond the end of their sentences? If they are kept locked up until they are well – so that they aren’t a danger when they’re released? Does anybody object to this?

Mentally-ill, sexually-violent prisoners object, and their lawyers. And they discovered that they had judicial allies: trial judges and justices of Court of Appeal. Some of these judges and justices ruled that Congress had exceeded its authority by passing the law that kept these prisoners confined.

                 1. The prisoner’s argument: the enumerated powers of Congress.

 The prisoners' argument was simple: the law was unconstitutional. Congress can’t pass laws that the Constitution doesn’t authorize. Art. I, sec. 8 of the Constitution describes the kinds of laws that Congress can pass. Think of Art. I, sec. 8 as a basket of congressional powers in the Constitution.

And none of the powers in that basket specifically authorizes Congress to pass laws to confine mentally-ill, sexually-violent prisoners. Ergo: the law crashes against the Constitution and sinks below the waves. So the argument went.


2. The Supreme Court disagrees.The Supreme Court disagreed. To reach this conclusion, the Supreme Court called upon the so-called "Necessary and Proper clause". That clause comes at the end of Art. I, sec. 8. It says:

The Congress shall have Power - To make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof.
                   3. The Supreme Court’s reasons.

Now, in this basket of Congressional authority, there is no authority to punish or imprison. That authority is nowhere expressed. But there is other authority. And the Supreme Court has said that the power to punish and imprison is "necessary and proper for carrying into Execution" that other authority.

In other words, the power to punish and the power to imprison is necessary and proper to carry out other authority given to Congress by the Constitution, even though the power to punish and imprison is not expressed in the Constitution.

So: Art. I, sec. 8 (the "enumerated powers" of Congress) authorizes Congress to enact laws "[t]o establish Post Offices and post Roads . . .." Because Congress has the power to establish post offices, Congress has "necessary and proper" power to pass laws to punish persons who steal mail. And because it has the power to punish persons who steal mail, Congress has "necessary and proper" power to enact laws to build prisons to house persons convicted of stealing mail.

Other examples abound. Congress can punish and imprison for civil-rights violations and voting-rights violations because of the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments. It can punish and imprison for embezzlement of federal funds because of the Spending Clause. Congress can punish and imprison for perjury under its authority to create federal courts. The list goes on.

And the Supreme Court said that the power to civilly commit mentally-ill, sexually violent prisoners derives from its power to imprison, which derives from its power to punish, which derives from its power to regulate under specified authority in its basket of powers.

                    4. United States v. Comstock: the case that I’ve been talking about.

The case that discusses all of this is United States v. Comstock. It was decided in May of 2010. Five of the nine justices joined the majority opinion that upheld the civil-commitment law. Two justices concurred; that means that they agreed with the conclusion of the majority opinion, but not necessarily the reasoning. Two justices thought the decision should have gone the other way. Justice Elena Kagan did not vote in the case. That was because, as Solicitor General, she argued the case in the Supreme Court before President Obama made her a Justice.


5. Alright.I, for one, am glad that mentally-ill, sexually violent prisoners can be civilly-committed until they are well enough so that they no longer pose a danger.

I’m glad, just like I’m glad that the Veterans Health Administration provides health care to veterans. Providing health care is not among the enumerated powers. But the power to "raise and support Armies" and to "provide and maintain a Navy" are. And the Veterans Health Administration, and the health care that it provides, are "necessary and proper" to carry out those enumerated powers. (To those who interpret the Constitution in a fundamentalist fashion: note the absence of authority to create and maintain the Air Force.)


6. What this means for the Affordable Care Act.The Necessary and Proper Clause will be important when the Supreme Court takes up the Affordable Care Act ("Obamacare" to its detractors). The solid majority that upheld the highly-derivative civil-commitment statute in Comstock gives supporters of the Affordable Care Act reason to hope. That solid majority included conservative Chief Justice John Roberts. And conservative Justice Samuel Alito concurred with the majority opinion. Justice Kagan did not vote, but she certainly would support the Affordable Care Act.

United States v. Comstock suggests a broad interpretation of the Necessary and Proper Clause. That makes supporters of the Affordable Care Act optimistic because persons who look to the courts to undermine the law argue that Congress exceeded it's authority in passing it. A broad interpretation of the Necessary and Proper Clause could only make it easier for the Supreme Court to rule that Congress had the right to pass health-care reform.

That might mean that, after the Supreme Court rules on the Affordable Care Act, parents can get health insurance for their children who are born with birth defects; sick people won’t die because they’re too old to stay on their parent’s health-insurance policy; and insurance companies can’t drop you because you get sick.

Here's a link to the opinion in United States v. Comstock:
http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/08-1224.pdf

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

What Gift Do I Have to Give My Wife?

What gift do I have to give my wife?
I’d love her, like she’d love me.
We wouldn't be lonely while the other lived.
And the breaking grief at the end of life
Would be prepaid hundredfold
By years of day-to-day joy before it.

Truth or Consequences

Would you take a drug if it helped you attain an immediate goal, but it also made you lose track of the frontier between reality and your imagination?

1. Reality impairment.As a lawyer, I encounter the (ahem) reality-impaired. I know a lawyer who described to a judge the contents of a document. But what he described was nowhere in the document. And I know that because he had given both the judge and me a copy of it.

He said that the document, a transcript of a meeting, showed my brother (my law partner) refusing to address the issues of the case, instead talking of nothing but the attorney’s fees he hoped to gain if we won. The lawyer meant to convince the judge that we were uninterested in justice and instead were motivated by greed and greed alone. But in reality, Peter discussed at length the issues of the case, and the subject of attorney’s fees never arose, not once. I know this because I read the transcript.

Another example. A lawyer described under oath his phone conversation with my brother. My brother hadn’t trusted him, so he had recorded his own side of the conversation. (You legally can do that without telling someone; but in California, you can’t secretly record both sides of a conversation). This lawyer made embarrassing accusations against my brother. But since Peter had recorded everything that he himself had said, he could supply to the judge, verbatim, his side of the conversation to refute the other lawyer.

I have known both of the lawyers from these examples for a while. One especially (he-who-said-that-my-brother-spoke-of-nothing-but-money) is a strategic liar. He says whatever wins. He’s untethered to the truth.

As years go by, more lawyers are like this.

2. The mind bent.I used to be amazed when someone stated facts that easily could be refuted. I used to believe that this showed audacity of deception.

But then I encountered the same phenomenon with a relative. In all sincerity, with nothing to gain by fooling me, this relative discussed fervently the contents of a document that simply were not there.

Like the two lawyers whom I have talked about, this relative uses falsehoods. If he is angry, he will lie to hurt someone. If someone has made a mistake, he might claim that apocalyptic consequences will flow from that mistake. ("Because of you, I’m going to lose $50,000!") He does this to burden his victim. His lies correctively.

Have lies dimmed the ability of my relative and these lawyers to know when they are telling the truth, and when their words only express what they wish were the truth? Does this happen when you use lies? When you use lies, do they make you blind?

3. The malleable mind.This conforms to what most people know about the mind.

For example, most people don’t remember their dreams. But if you want to remember your dreams, you should keep a pen and paper by your bed. When you wake up, immediately write down what you remember from your dreams. In time, you’ll remember your dreams without writing them down.

The act of writing down your dreams tells your mind that it’s important to remember them. Then your subconscious mind starts automatically to store them in a place that your conscious mind can reach.

Names are another example. If remembering names is important to you, you tend to remember names. I want to remember names. So over time I’ve taught myself to do so. I’m not great at it, but I’m better than I was. I’m better than most people who don’t care to remember the name of somebody they’ve just met.

Moonwalking with Einstein: The Art and Science of Remembering Everything is a book about memory. In one chapter, it talks about a memory experiment. For weeks, a test subject was tasked to remember random numbers. For weeks, his memory for randon numbers was ordinary. But then, he started to be really good at it. He became really good at it without training, just by constantly doing it.

The mind responds to demands put on it. It becomes stronger or weaker based on what it’s called to do over time.

Scrupulous truth-telling is like that. If you’re scrupulous about the truth, your mind responds by vividly delimiting reality. But when you wilfully choose falsehood, that tends to dilute the reality-delimiting power of the mind.

I hypothesize that scrupulousness about truth trains the mind to know reality. In contrast, a habit of lying instructs the mind that truth is unimportant. And it compromises the mind’s ability to know reality from imagination.

4. Proposed experiments.I wish psychologists or sociologists would put this to scientific proof. They could make test subjects do an exercise, success at which will earn the test subjects something that they value. Then the test subjects can be asked to self-report the outcome, not knowing that they had been watched. Then, they could be given a test to determine their ability to distinguish reality for un-reality. I’m supposing that the scrupulously honest ones will do better at this test than the others.

Or neurologists could study the brains of truthful persons, and compare them to those of known liars. ("Well, ladies and gentlemen, in 87% of liars, there was a 34%-or-more increase in the size of the mendacious-deludus portion of the brain.")

                    5. Doesn’t everybody?

Maybe a liar knows the line between truth and imagination, but not the difference between himself and someone who values truth. He himself little-values truth, so he assumes that everybody little-values truth.

So when he transparently lies, he knows that everyone will see through him. But he doesn’t care, because, in his mind, nobody cares about the truth. It’s not that he can’t handle the truth. It’s just the opposite: he can’t be bothered with it.

6. Truth or consequences.My personal observations drive these conjectures, and these conjectures have no better origin than that. But if I’m right, one day our society might not share the common ground of reality. Because as time passes, people become more and more untethered to the truth.

The habit of lying is like a potent drug that gives an immediate benefit, but it has terrible side-effects.

And over time, even the short-term gains will subside. Because in our time, people still tend to believe what they hear. A judge, for example, usually is slow to assume that the lawyer before him is lying. Because society is presently based, in large part, on trust. (Not too long ago, the term "liar" was a fighting word.)

But as liars multiply, trust diminishes. In time, credulity will wither. It will wither in law, in business, in journalism, in politics; then in teaching, then in church, then in family. And then we’re hammered. Truly, truly hammered.

Because a society that cannot share reality as common ground is a society of atomized reality. Atomized reality is chaos. A highly cooperative, integrated society such as ours cannot function in chaos.

                      7. A house divided.

 Lincoln knew that the nation could not survive half-slave and half-free. He sorrowfully but resolutely waged war that the nation would be all one or all the other.

So with truth-telling and lying. Truth-telling and lying don’t rule discourse and men’s minds and women’s minds equally like co-regents. One rises while the other falls. Society will move toward one or the other. There will be no stasis, no equilibrium. And to become a society of liars is dreadful to contemplate

                     8. Back from the brink.

 Most of us are limited in our influence. We have great control over ourselves; some influence over our loved ones and friends; and little influence beyond our immediate circle.

That doesn’t make us helpless. Our solution to the encroachment of falsehood lies in furrowing our souls in straight lines. Our solution is to be zealous in truth - fanatical, even. If we are zealous, we can often influences our circle of acquaintances by our example. If heaven blesses the effort, then the virtue of truth will ripple outward in circles of verity that spread wherever someone commits himself to truth.

It will take a movement like this to rescue ourselves from what we are becoming, because now all the expansion is in the other direction. Liars plant lies. They arrogate to themselves a God-like authority to invent a world to their liking with nothing more than will and words.

We must not as a nation swallow that poison.

Saturday, March 26, 2011

Humor Now


A writer on Facebook thinks that jokes about the abortion controversy are outside of good taste and untethered to reasonable restraint.

Maybe she should lighten up.

Yes, sometimes things happen that are too serious to joke about.  Even The Daily Show went on hiatus after 9/11.  There is a time for everything, and the time is not always for making jokes.

But censure of humor sometimes has nothing to do with time and taste.  Often, it has to do with hostility to the point of view expressed humorously.  A person who despises a joke about the abortion controversy might – might – think hilarious a photo-shopped picture of President Obama as a bone-in-the-nose witch doctor.  So when somebody criticizes something that I smiled at, I don’t necessarily put on my shame face.

Timing and taste are important.  They are also subjective.  One person might be ready to see humor in something earlier than another.

So a German tourist couple was strangled in Bolivia and their bodies were returned to Germany.  Before they left for their exotic vacation, they probably expected to return and be surrounded by friends eager to find out about their adventure in the Third World.  And, in fact, when they returned to Germany, their friends did gather around them.

That is an irony best unmentioned at grave-side.  But as a comment on the irony and unpredictability of life, ghoulish as it is, it might be worth mentioning at another occasion.  And, certainly, a hard knot of grief might be massaged after the funeral by mourners trading light-hearted stories about their dead friends.

Another example.  I am dismayed by Fox News.  I am dismayed by incidents like their coverage of a D.C. rally featuring Sarah Palin.  Fox News showed a teeming crowd on the Washington Mall.  But the teeming crowd was from a different, better-attended rally.  You could tell that by looking at the foliage on the trees in the background.  (As pointed out by The Daily Show.)  And Fox’s coverage of the public-worker protesters in Wisconsin featured an unruly man shoving another man – with palm trees in the background.

I find these examples emblematic of Fox News.

Now, when he was on the air, Keith Olbermann blasted Fox News with indignation.  That indignation made Fox News seem big and dangerous.  Which they are, because they effectively masquerade as a news organization, and they are zealously followed.  But they are really an American version of The People’s Daily, a Chinese newspaper that I read for lack of a better option while I lived China.  So good on Keith Olbermann.

But good on The Daily Show for cutting Fox down to size by showing how their slavishness to conservative ideology makes them ridiculously manipulate “news”.

Is it really necessary to defend humor?  It’s not hard to do.

Humor is inherently creative.  It can shake us out of customary mental paths.  That can lead to good approaches to problems.  I talked with my brother about a brief written by an opposing lawyer.  The judge had requested briefing on an issue.  The opposing lawyer made a weak attempt to address the issue, then wrote an attack on our motives and characters.  I remarked, “If the law and the facts are against you, change the subject.”  It was a little bit of humor in lieu of angst.  It’s going into my reply brief.

Humor diverts.  Unhappiness comes; humor can make it a little lighter.   In law school, I had a happy apartment-sharing arrangement with two women.  While one of them, a beautiful, charming woman, was on vacation, she sent me a letter.  The letter asked me to move out.  My sorrow at being asked to move out was leavened because I could see humor in the contrast between the message and my initial joy of getting the letter.  Later, I shared this with the letter-writer, and we laughed.

But is there a difference in stolen laughs over little things and humor about the wider, dangerous world?  There is no question that the world is a very serious place right now.  Ours is a world of threats and menace.  Our material comfort is at risk and, I believe, we cannot take for granted the continuation of democracy in America.  Just to say two things.

In serious times, humor is an act of courage.  Fritz Gerlich wrote a satiric article in a Munich newspaper about eugenics-crazed Adolph Hitler.  He asked, “Does Hitler have Mongolian blood?”  That was courageous.  Gerlich was murdered in Dachau.

Sometimes humor is optimism. Persian king Xerxes sent word to Spartan king Leonidas that Persia’s arrows unleashed against the Spartans would “blot out the sun”.   Leonidas replied, “So much the better, we will fight in the shade.”

Sometimes humor is resignation, or hoping for the best in a bad situation.  We can’t do anything about the evil in the world, so we might as well grin and bear it.  If humor helps us to grin and bear it, fine.  So, in “Fiddler on the Roof”, the rabbi says, “A blessing for the Tsar? Of course! May God bless and keep the Tsar... far away from us!”

But again, time and place are all-important.  Winston Churchill didn’t start his “blood, toil, tears, and sweat” speech by warming up Parliament with a humorous anecdote.  Nor did Abraham Lincoln crack wise in the Gettysburg Address.  But Winston Churchill had a keen wit, and Abraham Lincoln was a genius teller of humorous stories.  Time and place.

So, to the woman who tolerates no jokes about the abortion controversy: you’re entitled to your opinion.  Bless you.  Who knows, maybe you’re right.  If I do the Long Fall after Divine Judgment, maybe it will be because, in my time on Earth, I wasn't serious enough.  That might be.

But I think that the salient sins that will eject me from eternal joy will have a bigger bore than jokes I’ve told or secret smiles at shocking quips.  And if the world is a waiting room for eternal compression, I won’t change it into the backstage for eternal expansion by never cracking a smile.  Nor will anyone, I think.

And if there’s humor in Hell, I’m sure I won’t enjoy it.  So on Earth, let me laugh.

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Unstoppable Death

My friend Robert is dead.

He was younger than me. It was cancer.

As I thought of Robert today, my mind drifted to old movie monsters. They were slow moving -- almost laughably so. But even so, they were scary in their time. They were slow, but they didn’t sleep. They never rested.

Like death itself. When we're young, death is easy to outrun, if we’re even aware of it lurking somewhere out there. It can’t catch up to us when we're young. It can’t catch us unless we fall. It can’t catch us unless we succumb to some unexpected catastrophe that takes away our power to run away from it.

Like Robert -- Robert, on his death bed, unable to arise, unable to run away. In his wasted weakness, he couldn't fend off death, couldn't outrun it.  The slow-moving monster got past his doctors, got past his family, got past his guardian angels, and it took him.

It made him dead like itself.

Based on our knowledge of the arc of life, we know that one day, like Robert, we also will be in a state of mortal helplessness. We slow down. We tire. We know we need sleep. We begin to know the danger of that slow-moving monster that doesn’t sleep – that monster with it’s fatal persistence.

Science places barriers between us and the monster. So does wealth, health, and nutrition. But that dogged monster overcomes all barriers sooner or later.

And it can’t be killed. Because how do you kill death?

It starts its unstoppable journey to find us as soon as we possess life. It might start from far away, or from nearby. It might have many miles to travel before it finds us, or few. But whether many miles or few, the meeting must come.

It must come, and we know it must come, but we usually don't think about it.  Until we do.  Until it takes a friend or a relative.  Then we might resolve to eat healthier, exercise more, or visit the doctor for a checkup. We do these things hoping to put more miles between us and our tireless pursuer.

The last time I saw Robert, we were in a grocery store. It wasn’t that long ago, but it was before he knew he was sick. I was at the end of the checkout line, and he came from behind and bumped me, hard. In fun. I turned to see who bumped me. When I saw it was him, I smiled, put my arm around his shoulders, and said, "You don’t know how close you came to going unconscious."

Robert leaves a son and a daughter entering adulthood, and a wife.

Saturday, March 19, 2011

Top ten reasons why an adult has to accompany a child into an R-rated movie.


10. To make sure the child doesn’t sneak into a G-rated movie.

9. It’s a form of public shaming for the adult.

8. So they can both be embarrassed.

7. To increase ticket sales.

6. To encourage quality "together time".

5. Because it’s cheaper than a brothel.

4. It’s the Motion Picture Association of America’s gift to pedophiles.

3. So the adult can explain the finer points of what they saw to the child.

2. So the child can explain the finer points of what they saw to the adult.

1. Because after the cow is out of the barn, it’s not too late to close the barn door.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Dumped!

She was an attractive Latina lawyer, my age. She was fit, smart, and religious.  I was dating her.

Was.

She broke up with me by e-mail.

In the e-mail, she talked about her life. She talked about her struggles and what she had to overcome. And she concluded that I was not as tough as she was. And that was unacceptable to her.

I acknowledged her wishes and wished her "good luck".

That might not have been much of a response. But she had just virtually called me a wimp. If I had written a sensitive, nurturing response, she would have accused me of lactating.

So it’s over.

Fine.

She didn’t have to tell me why she was breaking up. "I want to break up" is a fully sufficient reason. In my experience, women act like men can sue them if they don’t have a good reason for ending the relationship.

But in my experience, most men would rather not know. Because let’s face it, most women can come up with a pretty good reason. And that doesn’t build the guy’s self esteem.

But at the same time, if she didn’t say why, I would have been curious.

Still, I take the reason with a measure of skepticism.

That’s because of my philosophy of dating. I believe that some relationships are inherently hardy. Others are inherently weak. Only time reveals whether you’re relationship is hardy or weak. A hardy relationship will survive or thrive in circumstances that would drive the partners in a weak relationship apart.

In truth, I used to torture myself after break-ups. I used to say, "If I had only said (thus-and-such)!" Or "If only I hadn’t said (whatever)!"

But that was a long time ago, and I don’t torture myself that way any more. Because now I believe that when a relationship works out, or doesn’t, it has to do with who the people are on a deep level. The you-said-that stuff, or the you-are-thus-and-such stuff – these are just surface observations that might hint at the deep reasons why the relationship did or did not work. Or they might not.

If anything irritated me about the heave-ho, it was her attitude – sweet in its way – that she knew that I was going to be crushed by this. In fact, I liked her, and I was pursuing her for a reason, but I was not crushed.

After passing through many years, I have a certain fatalism about relationships. I use baby turtles as a metaphor. When I was young, I saw a National Geographic episode about sea turtles. The mother turtle lays her eggs in the sand. Predators eat some before they hatch, or they get stepped on by humans or animals. Of the baby sea turtles that hatch, some are eaten by predators on their way to the sea. In the sea, there are many more predators. Few sea turtles survive to adulthood.

To me, relationships are like baby sea turtles. It’s remarkable when one matures to adulthood. It’s un-remarkable when one doesn’t.

That attitude is consolation when a relationship doesn't work out. Also, for consolation, nothing beats sour grapes.

One of her stand-out qualities is her strict morality. Before the break-up, I saw her strict morality as a tonic from the disintegration of morality in the larger society. Her uprightness was admirably against the tide of a society that increasingly has bad values or no values at all. But after the break-up, I started to think, "If she were any more ‘principled’, she would wear a burqa."

Even with such consolations, I was not unaffected by the break-up. I got her e-mail this morning. All day, I was more irritated about things than I otherwise would be. So she hit a raw nerve.
    
But raw nerves heal. I think things are more tragic to young people, because they are not inured to disappointment. But we survivors of five-or-so decades know disappointment. Sometimes we even know tragedy. Over time, I have suffered great shocks. Compared to them, a break-up is a small thing. Life’s disappointments and shocks put every new unhappiness into perspective.

And compared to all of the tragedy in the world, this is very modest suffering. Thousands of people in Northeast Japan would swap misfortunes with me in a nanosecond.

So, I’m OK with her choice. Not happy, but OK.  I wish her well. And tomorrow is another day.