Saturday, August 20, 2011

Does God Have an Immigration Policy?

"Use every man after his desert, and who should ’scape whipping?" – Hamlet, by William Shakespeare
We have a disconnect between how we judge others, and how we hope God will judge us.

1. The never-ending debate.

I have friendly debates with friends about illegal immigrants. From my point of view, people have assumptions about illegal immigration, and these assumptions don’t hold up. For example, people assume that there are a limited number of jobs, so that every job taken by an illegal immigrant is a job lost to a citizen.

This assumption doesn’t hold up when it’s studied by economists. Economists find that illegal immigrants create as many jobs as they take. Money doesn't go to illegal immigrants and stop. They spend it. That spending creates jobs. So illegal immigrants don’t just eat the pie; they make more pies. They make pies as fast as they eat them.              .

So I don't think that the facts are on the side of my debate partners. But sooner or later in my friendly debates, the argument becomes a moral argument. Sooner or later, my friends resort to this argument: people shouldn’t come to the country and break the law. And by coming to the country, illegal immigrants are breaking the law.

It’s a fine argument. After all, people should obey the law. Who can endorse law-breaking?

Who wants to be on the side of law-breakers?

2. God and grace.

Well, Jesus.

Yeah, him.

The guy who said:
But go and learn what this means: "I desire compassion, and not sacrifice," for I did not come to call the righteous, but sinners. [Matthew 9:13; NASB.]
To know God and to know yourself is to know that "[B]y grace you have been saved through faith; and that not of yourselves, it is the gift of God; not as a result of works, so that no one may boast." (Ephesians 2:7-9; NASB).

We need grace when we stand before God so that our own too-scrupulous words don’t return to judge us when we crave mercy. I would not want to be judged by the parable of the slave who’s debt was forgiven by his king, who then threw into prison a debtor who could not pay a debt to him. (Matthew 18:23-35.)

"On Earth as it is in Heaven" means that we must strive to be like Christ.

3. On Earth as it is in Heaven?

That doesn’t mean that we lock up the Penal Code instead of locking up law-breakers. It does mean we pray for the grace to know that we need grace. It does mean we pray for the grace to know when we should confer grace, and when we should withhold it. It does mean we think hard about these things.

When I was a relatively new Christian, I worked at a law firm and had a secretary who undermined me in every way she could. Yet I knew that Christians had to forgive, so I tried and tried to forgive her and to return good for evil. All I ever got back was evil. I finally decided that if it was alright with God for me to hold that job, it was alright with God for me to try to get that secretary fired. Which I did. That is, I tried. In fact, she wasn’t fired until the day I quit the firm.

The point is that I know that it’s hard to model God’s grace; sometimes, it’s impossible. For me, that’s true.

But it’s more possible than a lot of people think.

At the very least, we should not necessarily demand strict obedience to laws, when no harm actually is being done. We should understand that judging others in legalistic strictness is not the righteous, unanswerable argument that it seems to be.

4. Obama, immigration, and grace.

The Obama administration is coming under predictable attack for extending grace to good kids – kids who came to the country illegally as children, who have stayed out of trouble, who want to go to college or join the military. The Obama administration has decided not to bring deportation proceedings against these good kids. Instead, the Obama administration wants to use more resources to eject illegal immigrants who commit crimes and harm our country.

I think that’s a sensible policy. I’m proud of the president for it.

I prefer the president’s plan to the attitude of my friends.

5. My hypocrisy.

But I’m a hypocrite. I pretend to be gracious, but I’m not, because I judge my friends. I act like they are hypocrites, who rely upon grace but are not gracious. Well, they are human, so that’s probably true. But it’s true of me, too, every day.

Maybe they just calibrate grace differently than I do.

But that’s the debate: it’s not law-breaking versus not-law-breaking. It’s lawbreakers learning by grace how much law-breaking we should tolerate, especially when that lawbreaking does no harm.

And it’s knowing that we're not born citizens of Heaven. We don’t earn citizenship. If we enter Heaven, we enter by grace, and by grace alone.

____________________________________

The Obama Administration policy:

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/19/us/19immig.html?scp=2&sq=illegal%20immigrants&st=cse

A paper on the net effects of illegal immigration:

http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/Files/rc/reports/2010/09_immigration_greenstone_looney/09_immigration.pdf

Thursday, August 18, 2011

God in the Classroom: A Manifesto

Sshhh! Let’s conspire.

People complain that the Supreme Court banned God from the classroom in the 1963 case Murray v. Curlett. But there’s a way to get him back.

It’s real simple. It’s real subversive.

See, God dwells in the hearts of those who love and fear him.

See where I’m going with this?

So it’s simple. In our homes, in our churches, teach our children to love and fear God. Then send our children to school. When our children enter school, God goes in with them, carried in their hearts.

It’s so simple!

The problem is that people sometimes talk like we need teachers to lead Christian prayers and read the Bible in classrooms, in front of students who are Christian, Jewish, Buddhist, Muslim, Hindu, atheist, and agnostic. That, apparently, will install God in the hearts of the students, so the students can carry God back to their homes and churches.

But these people, in their complaints, have it all backward. It’s supposed to work the other way around.

True, my plan has at least two problems. The first problem is that it takes effort by parents and pastors. Because to really, really work, this plan demands that children learn to be little Christs. To really, really work, our Christian children must go into schools and act in a way that the non-Christians see a difference in them that they want for themselves.

And that calls for discipleship. That calls for study, prayer, and meditation – by the parents, by the pastors first, then by the children.

That’s because Christlikeness does not arise in the lazy Christianity that glories in being saved but makes no effort to deepen a relationship with the saver. That relationship – like any good relationship – demands time. And it demands time from the parent and the pastor before they can reproduce it in the children.

And here’s the second problem: the success of this plan is not guaranteed by the efforts that parents and pastors make. This Christian Normandy Invasion of the classroom is no more guaranteed to succeed by our efforts than that other Normandy Invasion. There’s something else that this plan requires, and it’s something that we have no control over.

That’s grace.

Study, prayer, and meditation don’t automatically lead to Christlikeness. Online, you can listen to sermons from the Westboro Baptist Church (they who celebrate the deaths of our soldiers). They know their Bible. They know it well. They just have a flawed understanding of it. It defies my understanding of the in-dwelling Christ to say that Christ dwells in them.

The South went to war against the Union to preserve the institution that permitted them to eat their bread by the sweat of other men’s faces – Black men’s faces. They were a praying, preaching, Bible-reading people.

The overwhelming majority of Germans were Christians. But they followed Hitler into World War II and the Holocaust.

So study, prayer, and meditation lead to spiritual wastelands without the grace of God. And nobody can make God give grace.

But nobody can stop us from praying for grace.

So pray for grace, for yourselves and for your children. Then study, meditate, and continue to pray, and teach your children to do likewise.

Then nothing but God himself can keep God out of our schools.

Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Homage to My Facebook Friends

Sometimes, Facebook is like a hammer blow to my hand that I can’t live without. I’ll explain.

If Abraham Lincoln lived today, I think he would be on Facebook.

Lincoln lived before public-opinion polls. He had to gather his information about what people were thinking in old-fashioned ways.

He read newspapers.

And he talked to people.

He lived in a time when a man or a woman of no fame could walk into the White House and demand an audience with the President – and get it. He lived in a time when the President walked the streets. In fact, people felt so comfortable with Lincoln that they would ask him for money. One day, he had to tell a man that he couldn’t give him money, because he had given away all the money that he had started out with.

So Lincoln as president lived among the people, and he knew about them firsthand.

I’m not exalted (and isolated) like the president of the United States. But we live in an atomized age. That is, I don’t think that people today join groups where they mix with people very different than themselves. People today are more socially self-contained. Our lives follow the rut of work, family, TV, and, increasingly, the internet. And friends tend to be like-minded. And the programming and websites that we choose tend to confirm our beliefs, instead of challenge them.

That’s not completely true of me. I sometimes go to a conservative church, and I suppose that most people there are politically conservative. (Can I generalize and say that conservatives make the best preachers? Maybe. But my exposure is limited.) And I have my newfound friends at the Masters swim meets – a diverse group.

But by and large I don’t have the wide access to people of different opinions that Lincoln and his generation had. That’s why I value Facebook.

On Facebook, I interact with people who have opinions that are stunningly different from mine. In fact, they have ideas about the world and reality that make it hard to believe that we live in the same neighborhood, city, state, or country. It’s almost like we come from parallel universes – theirs where Barack Obama is a secret Muslim; mine where he lives to make their lives better.

But it’s important for me to know their opinions. That’s true for a lot of reasons.

First, I grew up with many of these people. So they’re a permanent part of my life story, just like, in some way, I’m a permanent part of their life story. So to know what they’ve become and what they believe is to better know parts of the story of my own life.

Second, in this world, we share a common fate. If the country capsizes, it won’t be just Democrats or just Republicans who fall into the water. This is important because we live in perilous times. I don’t take for granted our continued prosperity, nor our continued freedom. I agree with those who sense a fragility in these things unrecognized by most people.

So I want to know my shipmates. I want to know who I depend upon to keep us afloat. I want to know who I’ll be treading water with if we capsize. To know who they are and what they think gives me a sense that I can see where the country is headed. This might be illusory. But it feels real.

Third, what my friends believe challenges my own beliefs. Reading the words of my Facebook friends makes me honestly ask: why do I believe the New York Times and not Fox News? I wouldn’t ask this if I didn’t have friends who gather their information and opinions from sources alien to me. It makes me put myself through a cognitive safety-check. That’s a good thing.

Fourth, there’s simple curiosity. Honestly, sometimes I read what my friends write, and it feels like I’m watching a small plane dive into a water tower. (They probably feel the same way about some of what I write.) But we humans have curiosity – even if sometimes it’s morbid curiosity. And sometimes it’s just interesting to know what other people think.

Fifth, politics makes me angry. I get frustrated by it. But knowing people who hold opinions that I hate reminds me that these opinions are held by people of good will. Of course, I believe that we all are innately evil – and I don’t except myself from that religious article of faith. But if the term "good" can be applied to the unrighteous hominids that we are, then I’m reassured that people who hold opinions very different from mine are "good" people. That keeps me from becoming a hater. That also is a good thing.

I’m grateful for the toleration of others. So far as I know, none of my Christian Facebook friends "un-friended" me after I wrote a blog called "When Christians are Assholes" and posted a link to it on Facebook. I’m sure that that wasn’t welcome on the Facebook news feeds of some of my friends.

This toleration gives scope to my opinions that otherwise I wouldn’t have.

By keeping me as a friend, my conservative friends show that they value some mix of the things I value about the diversity of Facebook opinions.

My Facebook friends might never make me believe that Obama is a secret Muslim. I might never make them believe that Obama lives to make their lives better. But their opinion is valuable to me exactly because it’s their opinion. I hope they value my opinion.

Monday, August 15, 2011

Ten Things that Liberals Believe - National Politics

In a few minutes, I wrote ten things that liberals believe. These relate to national politics (compared to international politics). It’s not an exhaustive list. It might not even be the top-ten things. But I think that these ideas are at the core of domestic political choices that liberals make.

1. Sick people shouldn’t die because they are poor.

2. In times of shared sacrifice, even the rich should share in the sacrifice.

3. Government of the people, by the people, for the people should be like the people. If people should be compassionate, government should be compassionate.

4. People should be compassionate.

5. Corporations are not people. Giving corporations First Amendment rights to spend unlimited money on political contests risks to drown out the actual people.

6. Big businesses, big banks have great power because they have great resources. They use their great power and their great resources for their own benefit, not for their nation’s benefit. They do things that harm the nation. It takes a strong government (of the people, by the people, for the people) to stand up to big businesses and big banks.

7. When we say that government is of the people, by the people, and for the people, we mean all the people.

8. In our time on Earth, humankind has built powerful technology. It makes our lives easier and better. But it also has the power to wreck our air and water and soil. We must use and control our technology to make sure that we pass on to our children and our grandchildren a cleaner Earth.

9. A nation is judged by how it treats its most powerless members.

10. Human rights are worth sacrificing for.

Sunday, August 7, 2011

When Christians are Assholes

I know an  old woman. She’s 92 years old and frail. She had a tidy sum set aside for her comfort in old age. But one day she owed a property-tax bill, and a snafu created a kink in her cash flow.

To her it was horrible to think that she might pay a tax bill late. So she went to her rich, rich daughter for help. The daughter is rich because of seed money supplied by her mother - the woman I'm talking about. To the daughter’s credit, she had managed that seed money shrewdly.

The daughter didn’t act out of gratitude to her mother. She didn’t lend money to her mother to spare her mother the embarrassment of paying a tax bill late. Instead, she coerced her trusting mother to put all of her property in an irrevokable trust controlled by the daughter. That meant that Mother lost control over her own property. She also lost the power to will the remainder of her property after she died to whom she chose.

Mother sued to regain control over her own estate. The rich daughter hired an expensive Orange County law firm to keep her money away from her. The daughter has wasted her elderly mother’s estate to keep it away from her mother. She has wasted her mother’s hundreds-of-thousands of dollars to do this.

The daughter has done this because she resents her brother, whom the old woman loves. She won’t be satisfied until the brother is ruined, and until her mother gets her nutrition out of a dumpster behind a doughnut shop. I am not being figurative. I mean this literally.

The daughter is "born again".

So I know up-close about Christians who are feces-flecked assholes.

I’m not a castaway in this knowledge of the deceitfulness of outward piety. Whoever knows scripture knows of this, too.

Jesus’s enemies drove nails into him and hung him to die in public in agony on cross-bars of timber. Before they did that, they spewed religious grievances against him. Their complaints were pious - too, too pious. He had grievances against them, too - he called them hypocrites.

Hypocrite comes from the Greek hupokrites. The Greek word means "actor, dissembler, pretender". (Shorter Oxford English Dictionary, Sixth Edition.)

Look at Psalm 55. The afflicted and tormented Psalmist speaks of his tormentor. His tormentor was his pious friend:

For it was not an enemy that reproached me; then I could have borne it: neither was it he that hated me that did magnify himself against me; then I would have hid myself from him: But it was thou, a man mine equal, my guide, and mine acquaintance. We took sweet counsel together, and walked unto the house of God in company.

Which brings us to the subject of today’s tirade.

Rick Perry makes it known that he wants to run for president. Then, suddenly, he is moved to hold a huge prayer rally, prominently featuring his pious, pious self.

Rick Perry IS Matthew 6:5:

And when thou prayest, thou shalt not be as the hypocrites are: for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and in the corners of the streets, that they may be seen of men. Verily I say unto you, They have their reward.

I piss on the piety of a man who holds a rally nominally to promote God, but really to promote himself. I piss on the piety of a man who clothes himself in love of God, who really wears his own ambition.

With this rally, Perry has made himself a Christian leader. Christian leaders take for themselves one of two Biblical texts. One or another of these texts is written on their souls. Imprinted on a Christian leader’s soul, one is good; the other is evil. I don’t need to tell you which is which. These two texts are:
He must become greater; I must become less. (John 3:30 (NIV).)
And I, if I be lifted up from the earth, will draw all men unto me. (John 12:32 (KJV).)
A man who decides to run for president and immediately features himself in a huge prayer rally has one of these written on his soul.

Guess which.

A man like that always has a few nail in his pocket, ready to pierce Jesus with them. This is true whether the public knows it or not. It’s true whether he knows it or not. Predators, hypocrites, fool themselves about their own piety before they fool others. And the more the public is fooled, the more the hypocrite fools himself.

Dread the prospect of a powerful hypocrite. Dread the prospect of a hypocrite ruling the country from the White House.

Friday, July 29, 2011

Glenn Beck, Evil, and Us

I am convinced that there will be no virtue in Hell. It will not exist there. Not even a residue of it.

Glenn Beck has the Lord's Prayer upside down: "On Earth as it is in Hell."

I say this because Glenn Beck compared the young victims of the Norway massacre to Hitler youth. The blogger who reported this (see below) states that Beck did not condone the killing. But Beck dips his finger in the water before he jumps in. For example, he claimed on Fox News that President Obama hates White people. He backed off when even his Fox News cohorts balked at his offensive accusation. But before he backed off, he offered this accusation to the world.

As to the Norwegian victims: before their toe tags had been taken off for burial, Beck gestured to a shadow of a justification for their assassination by a right-wing, Christian fanatic.

This sickened me.

1. Even Glenn Beck is complicated.

Yet I believe that human beings are complicated. To see someone as a cartoon villain instead of as a person with good and evil inside is wrong. My commitment to seeing complexity in humans makes me try to understand how Beck can be say something so sickening.

This goes against my instinct. My instinct is to say that when the Evil One speaks, Glenn Beck’s lips move.

But that would be wrong. So here goes my meditation on Glenn Beck.

2. Beck is disoriented by a mix of conservatism, Christianity, and evil.

Somebody deeply decent that I am related to condones torture. I was dismayed when I learned that. But I know that he strongly identifies with the Republican Party and with George W. Bush. This relative could see no evil in his president or party. So Bush’s endorsement of torture moved him to endorse it, too. I believe that the shallowness of President Bush is a falling light that caused shadows to rise among those who admired him. These shadows rose in my deeply decent relative. They took the form of considering a great evil to be a great good.

If he had been willing to see evil in the president – even if he saw good, too – my deeply decent relative’s morality would not have been darkened by Bush.

This shows how some people might idealize persons, and therefore not be able to see evil in them, to their detriment.

Now Beck. Beck does not so much idealize a single person. But he idealizes persons, like the assassin, who have qualities of Christianity and conservatism. To Glenn Beck, Christianity and conservatism, which the assassin embraces in the extreme, are good things. Perhaps to Beck, if Christianity and conservatism are good things, extreme Christianity and extreme conservatism are extremely good.

Could it be that Beck cannot recognize the evil effect of these things in the Norwegian assassin? Like my deeply decent relative, Beck might see a person as good or evil, not good and evil. Because he is a conservative Christian, this assassin, Beck might deep down want to see him as good or as mostly good.

If so, it must disorient him to see Christianity and conservatism and murder exist together in the Norwegian assassin. To restore his own mental equilibrium, Beck must find a way to reconcile this perceived goodness with murder. That involves contriving a way to make the death of the scores of victims not a bad thing, but somehow a good thing.

Naziism is a premier evil, so it becomes a handy label with which to blacken the blameless. Beck immolates the memories of the dead to preserve his ideology.

3. Beck might be acting out of anxiety for his followers.

Another explanation. Perhaps Beck considers his ideology to be an ark in dangerous seas. Himself an extremist, perhaps he worries that this proof of the evil of extremism, Christian extremism and conservative extremism, will demoralize his followers. Beck might fear that this demoralization will make some of his followers jump off his ark, to their peril. So it is out of compassion that he stains the memory of the dead – compassion for those who listen to him.

4. But that doesn’t make defaming the dead right.

This is the best that I can do to explain what Beck has said. I know that what I write is shallow and unsatisfying.

Even though I try to explain what Beck has said, I don’t justify it. Evil with a reason behind it is still evil. To say that there is some compassion or logic mixed in with what Beck says is not to say in any ultimate way that he is a good person. It only acknowledges that he is a complicated person.

5. Making peace with Glenn Beck.

But to say that Beck is complicated is to concede his humanity. To say that Beck is complicated is to say that he is like me and like every person that I know. We differ only in degree, because nobody is entirely good or entirely evil.

The Norwegian assassin had one kind of extreme Christianity. Another extreme Christianity – let me distinguish it by calling it radical Christianity – calls us to recognize our universal moral poverty before God. With the prophet Isaiah, we are called to say:

But we are all as an unclean thing, and all our righteousnesses are as filthy rags; and we all do fade as a leaf; and our iniquities, like the wind, have taken us away. [Isaiah 64:6.]
Isaiah calls us to know our universal moral poverty before God. Having in mind this universal moral poverty, a Christian does not look upon a Glenn Beck and say, "There but for the grace of God go I." A Christian says, "There I go."

And if I look at Glenn Beck in this way, then I must say, "Glenn Beck is me."

_________________________

My source for Glenn Beck’s statement:

http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/07/28/a-madman-and-his-manifesto/

Tuesday, July 26, 2011

The Speaker of the House of Representatives, Yasser Arafat

I’m resigned to America's debt ceiling not being raised. America will default on her debt. Our credit rating will tumble, and the dollar will take a running jump toward losing it dominance among currencies. China and the Chinese stand to gain as the makers of the world’s future high-value currency.

America will transfer an additional trillion dollars to lenders’ hands to pay for her preexisting debt, because of the fall of America’s credit rating. This will make it more expensive for America to raise money. Obviously, we could have used this wealth for better purposes.

I became resigned when I saw House speaker John Boehner respond to president Barack Obama’s televised speech on July 25.

It reminded me of something that happened in 2000: the Camp David summit between Palestinian Liberation Organization head Yasser Arafat and Israel’s president Ehud Barak. To win peace, leftist Israeli president Barak made painful concessions. But Arafat rejected the best deal by far ever offered by Israeli negotiators. At the time, some people expressed that Arafat was perfectly happy to reject any deal, because refusal to compromise would win him the admiration of his constituency among the Palestinians. So peace floated into the ether, and Arafat let it float away.

John Boehner is playing Yasser Arafat in these negotiations. If the debt ceiling is not raised, because he insists on getting everything he wants and conceding nothing, Boehner becomes beloved of the hard-core Republicans who would hold the debt ceiling hostage to prevail in their position that only a minority of Americans share. Their position is that the long-term debt should be overcome solely with budget cuts, not with additional taxes on the wealthy. Republicans reject a ratio of budget cuts to new revenue of 83% to 17%. The new taxes would fall on the rich, who have benefitted disproportionately in increased income in recent years. Some of these very wealthy persons pay taxes at a lower rate than their secretaries.

So the government becomes dysfunctional.

Of course, Boehner wants it both ways. He won’t compromise, but he blames Obama for the coming debacle. This is from a party that lost all credibility when they proclaimed that the Health Care Reform Act had death panels. (Will someone please show me the death panels in that legislation? Because what was claimed to be death panels was only a provision (now removed) paying Medicaid doctors for doing what they otherwise would do for free: counsel elderly patients about advance directives for end-of-life decisions. That’s no death panel. If the death panel is something else, would someone please point it out?)

As Boehner blamed Obama in his speech, he told his story that there was almost an agreement, but Obama changed the terms of the agreement, and the summit fizzled (actually, Boehner walked out). I don’t believe him. I’m predisposed to disbelieve Republicans in Congress after the death-panel lies. And I watched Boehner closely as he told this particular story. I saw a glint in his eye as he told it.

That told me that Boehner is not only Yasser Arafat; he is also Lord of Facts. He arrogates to himself a godlike power to create facts in his own image.

This upsets me deeply. I shouldn’t be shocked; this is only a worse incarnation of what I’ve seen before. It’s playing politics with our future; it’s lying to play politics.

Maybe this is the moment of America’s final decline. Maybe this is the moment where ideologues in the minority rob America of her economic recovery and start the slide to a weak, dysfunctional republic. It sickens me. It disgusts me. It literally robs me of sleep.

The Republicans act as if they believe that when America capsizes, only Democrats will get wet. That won’t be the case.

A metaphor: in Greek mythology, Cassandra was the daughter of Trojan King Priam and Queen Hecuba. Apollo empowered her to see the future, but, when she wasn’t sufficiently grateful (in a particular way), he cursed her with the fact that nobody would believe her. She foresaw the fall of Troy, but she couldn’t convince anyone that her prophecy would come to pass.

I feel like Cassandra. Never in politics have I felt so frustrated. I foresee disaster brought about by corrupt practices. If Republicans are going to wreck the economy, let them at least be honest about their willingness to do so. House Majority Whip Eric Cantor was at least so honest when he said that the Republicans would not compromise on the budget, because they believe that agreeing to raise the debt ceiling was their compromise.

Remember that, and lay blame accordingly.