Showing posts with label power. Show all posts
Showing posts with label power. Show all posts

Thursday, October 10, 2013

The Weakling, Outsider King

The virgin birth of Jesus and Jesus rising from the dead are to many folks things of fiction, hope for the simple, flip-the-page fables.

To believers, they are simple truth. Why not? You can peer from the side of a mountain at sunrise. The distance of the stars, the sun rising, birdsongs as the sun brightens the land, the busy-ness of nature that uncurls with the sun’s rolling warmth – these make it believable that a virgin can give birth, and the dead can live again. If nature came from nothing, what is impossible?

1. The most amazing passage in the Bible?

That’s why, more than the immaculate conception, or the resurrection, or the Exodus from Egypt, or the four horsemen of Revelation, this might be the most amazing passage in the Bible. And there’s nothing supernatural about it. It’s very human. It takes place after Jesus is arrested.

[A]fter flogging Jesus, [Pontius Pilate] handed him over to be crucified. Then the soldiers led him into the courtyard of the palace (that is, the governor’s headquarters); and they called together the whole cohort. And they clothed him in a purple cloak; and after twisting some thorns into a crown, they put it on him. And they began saluting him, "Hail, King of the Jews!" They struck his head with a reed, spat upon him, and knelt down in homage to him. After mocking him, they stripped him of the purple cloak and put his own clothes on him. Then they led him out to crucify him. [Mark 15:15-20 (NRSV).]
2. Cruelty has reasons.

Why did these soldiers crudely disrespect Jesus? Maybe because:

He was a Jew. To Roman soldiers, that made Jesus an outsider. It’s the same when a White looks down on a Black; or a Muslim on a Christian; or an Indian on a Pakistani.

Also, he was weak. He was completely under their power.

And he was a law-breaker. So, as they saw it, he deserved the welts and bleeding slices on his back. Soon he would die a slow, painful death, and they were fine with that.

And he was a "king". And likely these Roman soldiers hated kings – or centurions, or emperors, or anyone else who they had to bow to, who kept them from having their own way.

3. Weakness.

It’s the weakness that most amazes. A cohort of soldiers pushed around, mocked, and spat upon the human expression of the God of gods.

And God permitted it.

This is the God who destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah with fire. This is the God who in one night slaughtered 185,000 soldiers besieging King Hezekiah’s Jerusalem. This is the God who calmed a storm with words.

This God stood by.

This forbearance was not an act of power. It was an act of character. The character, in its way, amazes more than the power.

Jesus’s act was an act of submission to humankind. And it was not submission to humankind in its nobility, wisdom, and compassion. It was not Good clasping respectful hands with Good. It was submission to humankind the shallow bully. It was submission to a cohort of soldiers that acted like a pack of jackals and debased a man about to suffer and die. They desecrated God, and God let them.

4. The Messiah.

The people waiting for the Messiah were waiting for a Psalm 66 Messiah. They were expecting, and wanting, a Messiah that would make his enemies "cringe", even if he also let others roll chariots over their heads.

They were expecting a Psalm 2 Messiah, who would break the kings of the earth with an iron rod and smash them like clay pots.

5. Jesus the un-God.

This Jesus was the Messiah? The world must wonder if we expect anyone to accept this. It goes against intuition. It does now. It did then.

But I choose not to fight that fight every day. The fight that breaks out in my mind more often than whether God is God or Jesus is Jesus, is this: what kind of Lord is he?

Everyone has a god. If they crave wealth, wealth makes them hop. If it’s beauty, or drugs, or liberalism, or learning, so be it.

But I want these words of Joshua tattooed on my heart:
Now if you are unwilling to serve the Lord, choose this day whom you will serve, whether the gods your ancestors served in the region beyond the River or the gods of the Amorites in whose land you are living; but as for me and my household, we will serve the Lord." [Joshua 24:15 (NRSV).]
Every day I pray for a pure heart, because I don’t have one. But the God of infinite might who gives his son over to treatment by we men described in Mark 15 – this God is perfect. He’s the God I want to serve.

6. The Jesus who is.

And this Jesus is the opposite of his oppressors.

They hated him because he was an outsider, and he was. But he spoke with the Samaritan woman. He told the story of the Good Samaritan. Jews hated Samaritans, but Jesus did not. And Jesus told his disciples to make disciples of all nations. There is no outsider with Jesus.

They hated him because he was weak, and he was. But he is close to the broken-hearted. He cares for the poor. And the blind. An the sick. And the dying.

They hated him because he was a law-breaker, and he was. But he kept company with sinners, and seemed to prefer them to the so-called righteous.

They hated him because he was a king, and he is. But Jesus loves his God and Father, and he submits completely to his father’s will.

I trust this Jesus. My salvation is safer in his hands than in my own.

7. Prayer.
Lord Jesus, day by day, bit by bit, please make me like you. Amen.

Monday, November 29, 2010

A Stench in the Nostril of God

Lies are a stench in God’s nostril. In the first ten Psalms, four condemn lies and deceit. In the third chapter of the Bible, Eden is lost because of a snake. Satan is called a "liar and the father of lies." (John 8:44.)

To a believer, God hath said should be the last word. It may be, or not.  And not everybody believes. So, God aside, here is a think-piece on truth and lies.

This is not "It’s nice to be good." This is a big deal. In Nixon’s "I’m not a crook";  in  Reagan’s   "[W]e did not - repeat - did not trade weapons, or anything else, for hostages"; in Clinton’s "I did not have sex with that woman"; and in Bush/43’s – well, look at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EYI7JXGqd0o – in all of these, our leaders pissed on public virtue. And America is fumbling with its zipper.

I don’t want to be preachy. But before we amble down into Gehenna with Richard, Ronald, Bill, and George, let’s look at the landscape of where we are headed. Let’s look back at what we are leaving.

1. Power.

Truth gives power to the weak.

In a court contest against a powerful adversary, a poorer, less-lawyered party can tell himself, "I have truth on my side". This declaration gives moral strength. It literally encourages.

And truth matters. By and large, judgment in court is based on truth. This is important, because a rich man can buy lawyers, but he can’t buy truth. If society values it, truth makes a legal contest more fair.

We expect that the party that should prevail in court can prevail. We expect that being right matters. Yes, our courts aren’t perfect. Sometimes courts convict the innocent. Sometimes courts give judgment against the righteous. But jurors try to rule right. They take seriously their duty to discover the truth. And that matters.

If judgment weren’t based on truth, it would have to be based on something else. Without judgment based on truth, judgment would be more often against the weak and for the powerful.

Like elsewhere. A former colleague of mine became a prosecutor in a court of another culture – I forget where. He told me that judgment there was based on the parties’ comparative status, not on the truth. And in Russia, jury tampering by the government is common. Russian jurors report government interference, but Russian judges do nothing; they even help the government. This happens because Russian courts exist not to determine the truth. They exist to vindicate the government.

These are examples of courts where truth plays a subordinate role. This is unheard of in America’s recent legal history. We assume that a court case is a search for the truth or falsity behind the charges. We may not perfectly find out the truth, but we try to, blunt as the effort sometimes may be.

But if truth is thought of as a shabby has-been, we lose the power of truth in our courts. We become like courts in other countries where truth is valued only if it meshes with any other goal of the court system – upholding the rich against the poor, upholding the insiders against the outsiders, upholding the government against the people. And that would be tragic for us.

2. Usefulness.

Truth is helpful.

Truth acts as a common ground. We might argue about values, but we fundamentally expect that we will agree on basic facts. If disagreement about facts separate us, we try to return to the common ground of agreed facts. If we did not intend for basic facts to be our common ground, the bedrock of our decision-making would be sinking sand.

Society makes life-and-death decisions based on facts. Do we go to war, or no? That depends upon whether our adversary is seeking weapons of mass destruction or not. Do we extend unemployment benefits to the unemployed, or no? That depends upon whether the unemployed need the benefits to stay afloat while they seek work, or if a government stipend squelches their effort to find replacement work. Do we reform health care so that sick people don’t die because they are poor, or no? That depends upon whether the reform includes provisions to kill old people (aka "Death Panels"). These are decisions where truth was needed to make right, crucial choices. These are decisions where people will choose wrong if they believe lies. These are cases in which lives will be wasted by a wrong decision.

People who inject truth into society’s debates help society make right choices. People who inject lies corrode society’s decision-making.

People also make important personal decisions based on truth. Sometimes my clients wobble about whether to take a plea bargain or go to trial. I often tell them, "I wasn’t there. You were. You know what happened. If the charges are true, then this is a fair deal. But if the charges are false, then no deal is worthwhile and you should fight the case in front of a jury." Most of my clients make the right decision.

3. Morality.

Morality presumes truth.

Lies are the servants of immorality. A man who gets between sheets with a woman not his wife tells his wife that he was driving home a co-worker. A person who destroys the innocence of a child denies molestation. A police officer who wrongfully beats a man claims that the man assaulted him. A politician who betrays his constituency says he acted on their behalf. A thief denies stealing.

Lies make a mockery of morality. Some people labor to do right, even when doing wrong would be easier or more profitable. But the liar cheaply gains the benefit of virtue by falsely claiming it.

4. Culture.

In our culture, we value and expect truth.

In romance, we don’t expect a suitor to woo a bride with lies. Someone who does is called a cad.

In medicine, we don’t expect a doctor to give us advice he knows is wrong. A doctor who does is called a quack.

In law, lawyers have a duty to speak truthfully to the judge Dishonest lawyers are called shysters.

In science, we don’t expect scientists to fudge data. One who does is despised in the scientific community.

In business, businesses are expected to be upright. We are shocked to be cheated.

We expect our friends to be honest with us. When we discover that a friend has lied, we loose trust in him.

The assault on truth turns back all of these expectations and values.

5. Conclusion.

Lies do to truth what forgeries do to currency. They debase it. They shake people’s trust in it.

When nominated as a Republican Senate candidate, Lincoln said:
A house divided against itself cannot stand'.(Mark 3:25) I believe this government cannot endure permanently half slave and half free. I do not expect the Union to be dissolved—I do not expect the house to fall—but I do expect it will cease to be divided. It will become all one thing, or all the other.
In truth and lies, the same must be true. Between virtue and evil, the middle cannot hold.

One last note. I started out saying that lies are a stench in God’s nostril.  I started out saying that to believers, God hath said may be the last word. But to be clear: in my observation, believers are not noticeably more truthful than non-believers. This makes me sad to behold believers.

Sources

For more on Russian government interference with juries: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/16/world/europe/16jury.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=russian%20juries&st=cse

Sunday, September 26, 2010

The Prisoner and the Politician, Part 3

(Parts 1 & 2 below)

7. Introduction, Part 3.

Part 1 compared two lives: a composite life-prisoner, and Newt Gingrich. Part 2 began to scrutinize the comparative virtues and vices of these men. Both have lied: Gingrich certainly, my client probably/maybe. Part 2 examined why.

8. The prisoner and the politician: comparison, continued.

 Let’s examine the comparative consequences of these character flaws, and other revelations.

d. The scope of their failings.Moral failings have consequences.

If my client lied about his knowledge of the murder of the house sitter, or his own participation in that crime, at least his lie had no scope. The commissioners and I were his audience, and we are few.

But Gingrich doesn’t lie to the few. He lies to a national audience. And he aspires to speak to the world as President of the United States with his unclean lips.

The scope of my client’s lies is minuscule. The scope of Gingrich’s lies is epic.

e. The effect of their failings.The consequences of my client’s – I suspect – minimization of his role in the murder is highly theoretical. A lie insults the dignity of the person lied to – here, the commissioners and me, whether we know of it or not. It has had no lingering effect.

When Gingrich lies, in addition to insulting the dignity of those he lies to, he deflects his audience from reality and molests their judgment. Based upon what Gingrich says, his credulous followers form opinions. Based on those opinions, they will choose candidates. And they will perpetuate his falsehoods among their friends and relations.

But almost worse than what Gingrich does to his credulous followers is what he does to his followers who penetrate his distortions. Because he is a hero to them, when they see him lie and rise, they are tempted to walk in his ways. This harms their integrity, and that potentially injures their personal and professional lives.

But Gingrich offends against more than his followers. He offends against the nation. Lies are toxic to our national lifeblood. On an individual level, any time we make an important decision – like whom to marry, where to invest our money – we crave accurate information. Who would marry if they knew that their would-be spouse was not kind, but cruel behind a mask of kindness? Who would invest their savings in a company, if they knew that the impressive company profits were only an accounting mirage? That's politics, too. America cannot sail itself to a safe and prosperous future under a delusion-based helm.

f. The burden of their failings.My client himself bears the burden his recent failing. He was caught with a cell phone, and he was denied parole. I have no doubt that he otherwise would have won release. As to his possible falsehoods, I feel no residual effect of this offense. Nor did the commissioners, if they were aware of it. I don’t think they shared my suspicion, because they said nothing. But minimization of personal responsibility for a crime is a fundamental reason for which commissioners deny parole.

Except in an eternal sense, Gingrich does not bear the burden of his recent failings; his followers and his country do. As Gingrich rises, we (potentially) fall.

g. Hypocrisy.My client is no hypocrite. He does not judge others harshly for what he himself does. He knows he has done evil. He hoped for mercy from the commissioners, but he was not dismayed when parole was denied. He did not complain about others who got parole who were, in his mind, less deserving.

Gingrich savages Democrats from his position of moral impoverishment. And as Speaker of the House, he famously made the case against Bill Clinton because of Monica Lewinsky. This, while he himself violated his vows to his second wife.

h. Goodwill.I don’t pretend that my client has affection for the commissioners who decide whether he goes free or stays in prison. But if nervousness is any indication, he fears them.

Gingrich possesses contempt for his followers. Contempt is the cause and effect of his falsehoods. Only contempt for his followers permits him to insult their dignity by lying to them instead of telling them the truth. And he necessarily must have contempt for people who cannot penetrate his transparent lies.


i. Humility and hubris.My client is humble. He doesn’t chafe under his daily routine, which is dictated by others. Others tell him when to rise, when to sleep; what to eat and when; what will be his occupation; what he may possess as property. He calmly accepted the decision denying him parole. He does not seek any lofty status in society. He just wants out. He knows he will always be under supervision, always be at risk for returning to prison. He accepts that.

Gingrich has wealth and power, and he seeks the highest power in politics. He considers his political rise more important than truth, and that is to say more important than God. Gingrich holds a bastard sense of entitlement to power – a sense of entitlement that overwhelms his fidelity to facts.

j. Future.If my client obtains his freedom, I have no doubt that he will lead a blameless life. For one thing, statistically, released lifers have a low recidivism rate. Also, after a deprived life, I expect the euphoria of freedom to choke out any depraved temptation that could cause his return to the futility of prison.

But it is hard to see a path to Gingrich’s rehabilitation. He has risen high in the world. He has the acclaim of millions. He has power, fame, and riches. And the consequence is pride. I see no catalyst that might alter the practices by which he has risen.


9. Conclusion.The life stories of my clients and Newt Gingrich are now being written. Some of my clients will achieve their freedom. Gingrich will rise, but I don’t know how high. But I predict this: in their small way, my freedom-gaining clients will lead good lives; and in his epic way, Gingrich will be a force for decline.